Israel denies reports of Hamas negotiations

Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is staying mum about a possible cease-fire deal with Hamas.
Israel’s prime minister denied media reports that it is negotiating with the militant group Hamas, which controls Gaza, but said there will be Israeli "consultations" Sunday "regarding the situation in the south."

“Should a decision of any kind be required, it will be made only via a meeting of the Security Cabinet and after taking into account all of the new political circumstances that have been created in the wake of the recent Israeli elections,” Yanki Galanti, the media adviser for Ehud Olmert, said Saturday night in a statement. The consultations are to take place among Olmert, Defense Minister Ehud Barak and Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni. Israel held elections Tuesday which resulted in a near-tie between Livni’s centrist Kadima party and the right-wing Likud party, led by Benjamin Netanyahu. It is not yet clear who will emerge as prime minister. Israel agreed January 21 to temporarily halt its three-week military operation in Gaza, which it began in response to repeated rocket attacks into southern Israel. Since then, Egypt has been trying to broker an agreement between the two sides. On Friday, a spokesman for Hamas told CNN that Israeli and Hamas negotiators have “almost reached agreement” on a long-term truce. Tahir Annono, who is in Cairo for the truce meetings, said there would be meetings Friday and Saturday, and on Sunday an announcement would be made.

Don’t Miss
War of words between Israel and Turkey sparks formal complaint

Israel centrists just keeping lead

Hamas: Gaza truce agreement near

Hamas’ deputy leader, Moussa Abu Marzouk, said that the truce would last for 18 months and all commercial border crossings between Gaza and Israel would be opened. The security of Israelis who have been targets of the rocket attacks from Gaza and the release of Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit are priorities as Israel considers the next steps in its conflict with Hamas, Olmert said Saturday through his media adviser. Olmert has been under pressure to secure Shalit’s release as part of a broader cease-fire deal. However, the cease-fire in January did not include Shalit’s release as a condition. Shalit was 19 when he was captured on June 25, 2006, by Palestinian militants in Gaza. They tunneled into Israel and attacked an Israeli army outpost near the Gaza-Israel-Egypt border, killing two other soldiers in the assault. Israel immediately launched a military incursion into Gaza to rescue him, but failed. “We should like to emphasize that the security of residents of the south and the release of Gilad Shalit are currently at the top (of) Israel’s priorities,” the statement said.

Share

Second boy claims to be dad in UK baby case

British Conservative party leader David Cameron has expressed his dismay over the case.
A second teenager has reportedly claimed to be the father of a child born to a teenaged girl in a case which has caused an outcry in Britain.

According to reports earlier this week Alfie Patten was only 12 when the baby was conceived with his girlfriend, Chantelle Steadman, 15. The Sun tabloid newspaper reported their daughter, Maisie Roxanne, was born on Monday. It carried photos and interviews with the pair and their child on Friday and Saturday. Alfie told the newspaper that he thought “it would be good to have a baby.” While Chantelle said they wanted to “prove to everyone” that they could give Maisie a “great future” and that they both planned to stay in school. However, on Sunday the Sun’s sister paper, the News of the World, reported that Richard Goodsell, aged 16, was claiming he was Maisie’s father. “I know I could be the father. Everyone thinks I am. My friends all tell me that baby has my eyes — even my mum thinks so. “Only a DNA test is going to sort this out properly. If I am the father, I have the right to know,” he told the News of the World. The situation has provoked a wide response, with Conservative party leader David Cameron telling the British Press Association that parenthood should not be something the teenagers should even have been contemplating.

Don’t Miss
13-year-old dad sparks outrage in UK

Octuplets’ mom seeks online donations

Prime Minister Gordon Brown said “all of us would want to avoid teenage pregnancies,” PA reported. Tony Kerridge, of the sexual health specialist Marie Stopes International, told PA that children needed better education. The response from CNN readers ranged from outrage to questions about whether the situation was actually rare. Allyson said exactly the same thing had happened in her home town. “Well, this is not news to my area. We had this same thing happen five years ago. Same aged boy and girl. They had a little girl. The dad graduated from high school the year before his daughter started kindergarten! He has full custody as the mom has moved out of town and had another child. I am glad the family has supported this child even though the ‘parents’ didn’t make a good decision in having a child so young.” Martha said she found the situation “very sad.” “I did not become a mom until I was 24 and it was still a struggle. I think these children’s parents should be held accountable. Where were they These kids have no idea what their lives will be like, finish school! Only if they are very lucky with a good support system.” Becky was dismayed. “This just shocks me and makes me sick… they are still kids! Only 13 and 15 year old! So where are their parents” Tell us what you think about the case

Share

The Warlords of Afghanistan

The Warlords of Afghanistan

Like many mothers in Afghanistan, Maghferat Samimi has affixed a photo of a child to her mobile phone. But the 2 1/2-year-old is not her daughter. She is a rape victim, one of scores that Samimi, a researcher with the Afghanistan Human Rights Organization, has documented in the country’s northern provinces over the past year. Witnesses to the child’s abduction by a local militia commander have had their rape claim backed up by a nearby hospital, but the district police chief maintains that the child fell on a stick. The chief’s objectivity in the matter, however, is hardly assured, given that he once worked with the militia commander.

In Afghanistan today, it can be impossible to know whom to turn to for help. Seeking justice from government officials, says Samimi, “is like going to the wolves for help when the wolves have stolen your sheep.” As the Obama Administration signals that it intends to devote more attention to the war in Afghanistan, many Afghans claim that in the name of fighting the Taliban, the West is ignoring abuses committed by its Afghan proxies. One of the worst offenders, alleges Samimi, is Abdul Rashid Dostum, an ethnic-Uzbek warlord who helped in the triumphant ousting of the Taliban in 2001, when, backed by U.S. special forces, he led hundreds of men on horseback to liberate the northern city of Mazar-i-Sharif. Dostum’s militia is accused of that war’s worst human-rights atrocity, in which hundreds of his captives suffocated to death after having been locked inside shipping containers. He denies the charges. Samimi is not concerned about Dostum’s wartime activities–few if any of Afghanistan’s leaders can boast clean hands after three decades of war. The problem, she says, is that the warlords and their militia commanders continue to commit crimes with impunity, protected by their alliances with foreign nations and comfortable positions within the Afghan government. A Criminal State Though they have largely relinquished their tanks and heavy artillery, several warlords have been able to maintain their core militias in the form of private security companies, political parties or loose business networks. Many derive their income from lucrative cross-border smuggling routes. Allegations of land grabs, rape, murder and kidnapping are common. Human Rights Watch and Afghan human-rights organizations like Samimi’s have documented extortion rackets operated by former warlords and militia-run prisons where captives are held for ransom. Afghan journalists covering these crimes have been harassed by police or thrown in jail. In 2007, Samimi received a phone call from Dostum threatening to have her raped “by 100 men” if she continued investigating a rape case in which he was implicated. Dostum denies ever making such a threat, telling TIME that the rape allegation is “propaganda.” And yet a witness to the phone call, military prosecutor General Habibullah Qasemi, was dismissed from his government post soon afterward, despite carrying a sheaf of glowing recommendation letters penned by U.S. military supervisors. The perception that warlords, protected by their influence and threats of violence, are not held accountable for their crimes has rocked Afghan society and fueled public discontent with the U.S.-backed Afghan government.

Share

World’s richest countries pledge to fix economy

Geithner: A common recognition exists among nations to restart credit markets.
The world’s richest countries committed to "any further action that may prove necessary" to restore confidence in the global financial system, their finance ministers said as they wrapped up a two-day meeting in Rome.

The Group of Seven finance ministers also urged countries not to close their markets to goods and services from abroad. “An open system of global trade and investment is indispensable for global prosperity,” they said in a statement at the end of their meeting Saturday. “Protectionist measures… would only exacerbate the downturn” in the worldwide economy. The ministers said the global banking crisis had revealed “fundamental weaknesses in the international financial system” and called for urgent reform. New U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, making his international debut at the meetings, called on governments to focus on stabilizing and strengthening financial systems and help restart the flow of credit. “Although the precise mix of measures must be tailored to each country’s situation — our financial systems are different, (the) structures of our systems are very different — there is a common recognition of more capital and government financing to help restart credit markets,” he said.

Don’t Miss
U.S.: Financial crisis spread to emerging markets

Italy hosted the meeting of the Group of Seven in its role as G7 president for 2009. G7 members are the United States, Germany, Japan, France, Italy, Britain and Canada. The agenda drawn up by Rome calls for adopting global measures and economic policy reforms capable of stabilizing the world economy and ensuring transparency to allow markets to function correctly. Geithner spoke just after the U.S. Senate gave final approval to a $787 billion recovery package to boost the U.S. economy. He told attendees that the package “provides a very powerful mix of investments and tax cuts to create jobs and to strengthen our long-term growth potential.” “As we act together to build a strong foundation for economic growth and recovery, we need to begin the process of comprehensive reform of our financial system, so that we never again face a crisis of this severity,” Geithner said. Another attendee, International Monetary Fund head Dominique Strauss-Kahn, said this week he supports such stimulus packages for advanced countries.

“The question is no more to convince the governments to move today, but for them to implement the policies they need to manage,” Strauss-Kahn said. He also warned of the dangers of protectionism, which he said may still come “through the back door, especially in the financial sector.”

Share

Venezuelans to vote on term limits for elected officials

Venezuela President Hugo Chavez waves to people in a poor neighborhood in Caracas on Friday.
Venezuelans will decide Sunday whether to change the constitution to allow President Hugo Chavez and other elected officials to run for office indefinitely.

The National Assembly approved the referendum last month. Venezuelans narrowly rejected a similar measure in December 2007. Results from this weekend’s balloting are expected from the National Electoral Council on Monday morning. If it passes, Chavez could run for a third consecutive six-year term in 2012. Chavez called for the referendum in late November, a week after candidates he supported won a majority of the seats in local elections. The elections had been seen as a test of his influence. The leader initially proposed that he be able to be reelected indefinitely, but after he had trouble convincing politicians and citizens, he proposed that the referendum apply to any elected official. Chavez, who spent his career in the military before entering politics, was elected president in 1998 as a leftist reformer, and instituted several reforms after taking office.

Don’t Miss
Venezuela ousts EU politician for remark about Chavez

He withstood a coup attempt in April 2002, which he accused the United States of fomenting, and a recall referendum in August 2004. In a parliamentary election in late 2005, Chavez supporters gained control of the National Assembly, and a year later he was easily reelected to another six-year term. According to the El Nacional newspaper, there will be representatives from all political parties at the polling stations. On Friday, Venezuela expelled a Spanish member of European Parliament after he called Chavez a “dictator” and criticized the Venezuelan president’s handling of the referendum on term limits. An opposition party, staunchly against Chavez, had asked Herrero to observe the voting.

In a statement, Venezuela’s Foreign Ministry said it had “invited” Luis Herrero, who represents the right-wing Partido Popular (Popular Party) in European Parliament, to leave the country to preserve a “peaceful climate” before the Sunday referendum. Watch how polling is expected to take place in Venezuela » Hundreds of students packed the streets of the Venezuelan capital, Caracas, earlier this month to march in opposition to the proposed amendment.

Share

UAE denies visa to Israeli tennis player

The UAE has refused to grant a visa allowing Shahar Peer to compete in Dubai.
The United Arab Emirates has refused to grant a visa to a female Israeli tennis player, preventing her from competing in the Sony Ericsson World Tennis Association Tour in Dubai, the WTA said in a statement Sunday.

The move runs counter to WTA policy, which says no player should be barred from competing in a tournament for which she has qualified. “We are deeply disappointed by the decision of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) denying Shahar Peer a visa that would permit her to enter the country to play in the Dubai Tennis Championships,” said Larry Scott, chairman and chief executive of the tour. “Ms. Peer has earned the right to play in the tournament and it is regrettable that the UAE is denying her this right. “Following various consultations, the Tour has decided to allow the tournament to continue to be played this week, pending further review by the Tour’s Board of Directors. “Ms. Peer and her family are obviously extremely upset and disappointed by the decision of the UAE and its impact on her personally and professionally, and the Tour is reviewing appropriate remedies for Ms. Peer, and also will review appropriate future actions with regard to the future of the Dubai tournament,” Scott said. “The Sony Ericsson WTA Tour believes very strongly, and has a clear rule and policy, that no host country should deny a player the right to compete at a tournament for which she has qualified by ranking.”

Share

For many Chinese, literary dreams go online

The Internet is increasingly being seen in China as a tool for literary empowerment, analysts say.
If it weren’t for the Internet, Murong Xuecun might still be working as a sales manager at a car company in the southern Chinese city of Chengdu. That is what he was doing when he started writing his first novel on his office’s online bulletin board system back in 2001.

Week by week when he got home from work, Murong would post new pieces to a story that painted a bleak yet honest picture of modern urban life in the city where he lived. It contained tales about sex, love, gambling and drugs and became so popular that it soon appeared on numerous other online forums. Today the 35-year-old is considered one of the most famous authors to have emerged in contemporary China. His debut work, “Leave Me Alone: A novel of Chengdu,” has been read by millions of Chinese “netizens” — steady Internet users — and adapted for film and television and translated into German, French and English. He also is viewed as a pioneer of what has become nothing short of an online literary renaissance in the country, particularly among young Chinese writers. This is a constituency that has struggled to find a platform for their work in a publishing industry that is viewed as conservative as it often faces state censorship. Instead of remaining silent, a new generation of authors has found its voice on the Web. “It is a very big revolution,” said Yang Hengjun, a political espionage novelist who published his first work online. “When you write something on the Internet that you can’t do in reality and you cause a change, that is revolutionary.” The past decade has seen the blossoming of countless literary Web sites and online forums hosting stories from thousands of aspiring authors. Their work is read by millions of Internet users, leading some to assert that in the future all writing, even reading, in China will take place in cyberspace. “It’s an inevitable trend due to the rapid development of the Internet and conceptual change of people,” said Hou Xiaoqiang, head of Shanda Literature, a division of Shanghai-based Shanda Interactive Entertainment, the largest online entertainment provider in China.

Don’t Miss
China tops world in Internet users

Special report:  Digital Biz

“Ordinary people have started to realize the world ought to be dominated by them, rather than some media or elite,” Hou added. “Online authors are breaking the rules and using totally fresh concepts.” Shanda Literature operates three of China’s biggest literary portals, including Qidian, one of the most popular. Collectively, the Web sites receive more than 200 million daily page views and have published nearly 30 billion Chinese characters, according to Shanda Literature’s company data. Shanda generates revenues through online advertising and by charging readers small amounts to access popular stories or works from famous authors who have been contracted to write. However, the company is increasingly trying to earn money by licensing online novels to film studios, music producers, game developers and book publishers while protecting the intellectual property rights of its authors. Shanda owns the rights to more than 200,000 works and has already sold a number of licenses to other entertainment companies, including a popular “Tomb Raider” novel that is being adapted for film by Hong Kong director Johnnie To Kei-Fung. “Literature is the starting point of all means of entertainment,” Hou told CNN. “It can provide numerous blueprints for games, music, movies and dramas. A lack of good stories is the main reason of the underdevelopment of entertainment [in China].” Many of China’s usually young and often female cyber-writers are posting their work online with the hope that, like Murong’s novels, their stories will be read by millions, ultimately becoming books or movies and turning the authors into celebrities. The online Chinese literary scene is, in some ways, like a TV reality show. Bookstores now have sections devoted to Internet novels published as paperbacks, while a number of other influential writers have emerged from the Web over the years, including Annie Baobei, whose books about love and loneliness in Chinese cities have sold more than a million copies. “In America, people have the American dream. In China, people have the online dream,” said Dai Yingniao, a college junior who says almost all of her friends read online fantasy novels about time travel, romance or some mixture of the two. These genres are mostly read by ordinary girls who find life boring, said Dai, noting her roommate especially fancies a novel from the Qidian Web site called “The Legend of Little Beauty.” “I prefer real literature rather than imaginary works,” added the 20-year-old. She then described a cyber-novel she is planning to write about a princess who lives during the Qing Dynasty. After leaving her home in Beijing, the princess returns to find she no longer recognizes her family or the society she had lived in a few years before. “I just want to convey my opinions about today’s life,” Dai said. “Sometimes euphemism is more powerful.” Today it is more accepted for Chinese publishers to take risks with voices emerging online, many now printing stories that simply would not have been possible a decade ago. Publishing houses often peruse Web sites for talent whose writing can be brought to readers who are not logged on. “Publishers can come in and say there are readers for this, and this is the demographic and if we want to hit young adults, then this is a great voice,” said Jo Lusby, the manager of Penguin China. “[The literary Web sites] are now a very natural part of the publishing scene in China. It is really a convergence of print and online writing.” Yet despite what has been a gradual commercialization and subsequent opening up of the Chinese publishing industry during the past few years, many of the writers who are able to self-publish with freedom online find they still can face substantial censorship when their works are adapted for offline audiences. “Offline publishing is still tightly controlled and not easy to change,” said Yang Hengjun, whose spy novels are banned in the country. “Any Internet novel is largely edited when it goes to publishing.” In the long run, however, Yang said he believes the freedom of literary expression on the Internet will spur even further liberalization in the Chinese publishing industry. “It is a good thing and it is a promising thing,” said Yang. “Nowadays for more and more people if they want to express themselves, they can go online.”

Share

Hunger Activists Want Al Gore to Make Another Movie

Hunger Activists Want Al Gore to Make Another Movie

From a distance, it looks like an ordinary movie poster. Pasted to a bus shelter wall along Madrid’s central Calle Segovia, it depicts a thin child looking upward toward credits printed in that look-at-me font that film-publicity posters seemingly always use. It’s only when you get close enough to read the title credits that you realize something is amiss. “Ask Al Gore,” one passerby queried his companion. “That’s the name of a movie?”

Not exactly. It’s the name of an advertising campaign designed to get Al Gore to make another movie — but not about what you think. By collecting enough signatures through www.askalgore.org , an international NGO called Action Against Hunger hopes to persuade the former Vice President turned climate-change activist to take on the issue of acute malnutrition: a remediable problem, the organization says, that each year kills 5 million children in the developing world.

No Hunger may not have the cinematic ring of An Inconvenient Truth, but its sponsors clearly hope that their appeal to Gore will do for malnutrition what his 2006 documentary did for climate change. “Gore is one of the most famous and media-savvy people on the planet,” says Juan Nonzioli, creative director of the Shackleton Group, the advertising firm that designed the campaign for Action Against Hunger. “Just as he has used that power to raise awareness about climate change, we’re asking that he use it for our campaign against hunger.”

The campaign, which was launched in fall 2008 in Madrid and will be rolled out in Paris, London, New York City and Montreal in the next few weeks, features both posters and a trailer for the as-yet-nonexistent film. But its main component is the signature drive. Thus far, more than 37,000 people have signed on to “Ask Al Gore,” including several well-known Spanish actors and writers.

Gore has yet to respond, according to Action Against Hunger. “We hope that when we launch the U.S. campaign, he’ll invite us for a meeting,” says Nonzioli. “That would be great.” But at his office in Nashville, a spokeswoman for Gore said he was currently busy with stimulus-package discussions. “They want him to put aside climate change and switch to world hunger” she asked, somewhat incredulously. Informed that the organizers hoped he would add the issue to his list of concerns, she conceded a bit. “It’s quirky, but I have to admit it’s a good idea.”

That’s what Action Against Hunger is banking on. The organization, which has offices in five countries, hopes to garner 100,000 signatures when it presents its petition to Gore this spring. But even if Gore decides to stick to climate change, the NGO says it can still claim success. “We have a strong message — that this is a disease that can be treated, that we can minimize the number of malnutrition deaths. We just needed a campaign that would make people listen,” says Carmen Gayo, spokeswoman for Action Against Hunger. “And we got one.”

See pictures of Ethiopia’s famine.
Read a TIME cover story on Al Gore.

Share

Reporter’s Notebook: Visiting Lincoln’s Springfield

Reporters Notebook: Visiting Lincolns Springfield

The best thing and the worst thing about Springfield is the same: the location. Middle of Illinois, which is not far from the middle of nowhere. The Illinois capital is about 100 miles from St. Louis, 200 miles from Chicago or Indianapolis. You can fly there, but probably not on a plane with much overhead bin space. More likely you will arrive at the end of a long car ride, having enjoyed wide vistas of flat prairies.

So the waves of change and tempests of progress that storm through more cosmopolitan places register in Springfield as the merest ripples and breezes. If this isn’t a place that time forgot, it is certainly a place that occasionally slips time’s mind. The dominant feature of the skyline is the Hilton tower, 30 stories high. It was built during the Nixon administration, and still feels like a hotel where Howard Hughes might be padding around with Kleenex boxes on his feet up on the top floor.

What’s great about this isolation is that Springfield still feels a bit like the city where Abraham Lincoln once strode the streets. There was more horse dung and dust then, to be sure. But nowhere else can you get such an intimate glimpse of the man in this bicentennial year of Lincoln’s birth.

It starts with the impressive job that the National Park Service has done with the Lincoln home, at the corner of Eighth and Jackson streets. If you stay at the Hilton, or the nearby Abraham Lincoln Hotel, you’ll have only a short walk to the house where Abe and Mary Lincoln raised their boys from 1844 until they left for Washington in 1861. The handsome clapboard two-story has been meticulously maintained by the Park Service, but that’s only the beginning. The federal government also acquired four square blocks surrounding the Lincoln home and — after removing all post-Lincoln construction — is restoring the neighborhood to its mid-19th-century look.

You see the home of the druggist and the house of the leather dealer, and the home of the state auditor and the little house where the divorced schoolteacher lived. You see where the Lincolns’ babysitter trudged home after a long stretch with the rowdy boys, and you see the spot where stood the home of Jamison Jenkins, a conductor on the Underground Railroad. It takes no great imagination to picture the enthusiastic parades and rallies that flowed through this street during Lincoln’s historic campaigns.

Tours of the Lincoln home are free, but you need a ticket from the nearby visitor’s center. The interior is wonderfully accurate, thanks to sketches of the family home prepared in 1860 for magazine readers eager to know more about their new president. In fact, much of the furniture is authentic — you can see the chairs Lincoln sat in, the desk he wrote on, the stove he stoked in winter. Mary used a chamberpot; Abe preferred the outhouse.

The home exudes a warm, middle-class prosperity, and in a small house across the street from the Lincolns, you can follow the steady rise of the young lawyer and family man. When Lincoln bought the place at Eighth and Jackson in 1844 — the first and only home he ever owned — he was a 35-year-old politician with a wife and a baby, and the house was a modest story-and-a-half. As he grew wealthier, Lincoln literally blew the roof off the place, extending it to a full two stories. Now there was space for big parties, a spacious guest room, and room for a live-in maid.

He’d come a long way from the log cabin.

From the home site, it’s an easy stroll past the church where Mary sought solace after losing a son, then onto Sixth Street. At the corner of Sixth and Adams is a replica of the law offices of Lincoln & Herndon, and across the street is the Old State Capitol .

Nearby is the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum, a modern, multi-media complex that houses one of the best collections of Lincoln materials in the world. As Illinois State Historian Thomas Schwartz explained to me recently, Springfield had the good fortune to have a Lincoln buff serving as governor during the Great Depression. He budgeted for acquisitions at a time when prices were low. “We were able to collect material at a time when there was not much interest and not much money.”

As a result, though the Library of Congress in Washington is the official repository of Lincoln’s papers, the library in Springfield has more items written in Lincoln’s own hand.

But if the library is a mecca for Lincoln scholars, the museum, opened in 2005, is pitched to appeal to ordinary visitors. Cannons boom at appropriate moments. Life-size figures of the Lincoln family stand poised in the light-filled central space. The late Tim Russert narrates a news report on the 1860 campaign, complete with television ads for Lincoln, Douglas, Breckinridge and Bell.

Behind the glitz, however, is a solid and reasonably full account of Lincoln’s life and achievements, with an admirably nuanced examination of the agonizing politics involved in emancipating the slaves. Perhaps the most moving artifacts on display are also the simplest — plaster casts of Lincoln’s craggy face and huge, rough hands, made by a sculptor during Lincoln’s life. Somehow, these more than any other exhibit capture the power and the gentleness, the strength and the fatigue, that defined Lincoln as president.

There are other Lincoln sites in and around Springfield well worth seeing — the train station where he gave his moving farewell address to his friends and neighbors; the home of Ninian Edwards, where the Lincolns met and courted; the reconstructed village of New Salem, where Lincoln launched his political career. Springfield also has been commemorating the 100th anniversary of a brutal race riot that terrorized the city’s black residents in 1908.

We learn from negative, as well as positive, examples.

Lincoln’s tomb looms over the Oak Ridge Cemetery not far from downtown Springfield. This massive granite edifice, decorated with statues cast from melted cannons and topped by an obelisk rising 117 feet, is a testament to the enormous place Lincoln occupies in America’s heart and memory. As if to remind us, though, of Lincoln’s genius for understatement, his burial marker inside is starkly simple — a name and two dates.

The last word on Abraham Lincoln appears on a wall above the marker, engraved in dark marble. “Now he belongs to the ages.” Edwin Stanton, Lincoln’s secretary of war, said it when his leader died at dawn on an April day in 1865. But it is never and nowhere more true than in Springfield on the day you make your visit.

Share

Rights Groups Probe India’s Shoot-Out Cops

Rights Groups Probe Indias Shoot-Out Cops

Scarcely a day passes in India by without news of an encounter between the police and criminals elements — “encounter” being the local jargon for shootouts involving the police, who are allowed to fire only in self-defense. On Wednesday, it was a “dreaded mafia don” who was gunned down by the Uttar Pradesh police — shot dead, and therefore unable to challenge the police account of the circumstances of the shooting. But some in India have begun to question the frequency of such “encounters”.

A national conversation was sparked by a January 25 encounter, in which two men were shot dead by police in the southeastern Delhi suburb of Noida. They were allegedly carrying documents proving they were Pakistani nationals, and were allegedly armed to the teeth to wreak mayhem on India’s Republic Day. Four Kashmiris were rounded up for interrogation, prompting a media frenzy about a “foiled terror attack”. Minister of State for External Affairs, Anand Sharma, quickly pointed a finger at Pakistan-based terror groups. “[The] Noida encounter shows that terror groups are still active in Pakistan, though we have repeatedly told Pakistan to dismantle terror infrastructure,” he told a TV channel.

Within two days, however, the detained Kashmiris were released, and it became clear that the investigations had reached a dead-end. That was when the media began to ask questions of the police account: Two terrorists tasked with staging a Republic Day attack on the national capital had stopped at a tea stall to seek directions; a police informer, who just happened to be present, spotted an AK-47 sticking out of a bag. An urgent tip-off prompted a dramatic chase and shootout, but the “terrorists” lived just long enough to “confess” their Pakistani nationality. Nor did it go unnoticed that this was the fourth such “encounter” between police and suspects in the same area in less than a month.

“Encounter” has been a dirty word in India for decades, especially since the Punjab insurgency of the 1980s and 1990s. Not only did an encounter allow the security forces to bypass the often slow and unreliable criminal justice system, it also brought promotions and gallantry awards. Human rights activists have for years protested the growing incidence of encounters, some of them allegedly staged. “Encounters have become the norm,” says Vrinda Grover, lawyer and human rights activist. “They have become the police’s preferred method to deal with not just terrorists, but criminals of all kinds.” Legends of “encounter specialist” cops abound, and one of them was even the subject of the Bollywood film Ab Tak Chhappan .

Activists allege that in numerous instances, evidence has been planted after a shooting in order to justify police claims that officers had acted in self defense. Encounters are meant to be probed by a magistrate following a post-mortem, but critics point out that the investigative work in such probes is undertaken by the police themselves. They also allege that such tactics enjoy tacit approval from the authorities in areas plagued by insurgencies. In 2003, a National Human Rights Commission proposal on new norms on encounters suggested that investigation on behalf of a magisterial probe be handled by a different police station from the one where the officers involved are based, but its recommendations have yet been adopted.

The growing incidence of encounters is viewed by some analysts as a symptom of police disenchantment with the justice system. “The system is so defective and the criminal justice machinery so lethargic that it takes years to bring the guilty to book,” explains G.P. Joshi, a former police officer now a consultant with the Commonwealth Human Rights Commission. “But crime continues to increase, and statistics show that conviction rates are down. This tendency promotes vigilantism in the public and the police. And the state also comes out in support, in consonance with public reaction.”

Public reaction is far from uniformly supportive of tough police tactics, however. A recent encounter in New Delhi’s Jamia Nagar district sparked a protest from members of the Muslim community, who claimed that the police had presented no evidence to back their claim that the two Muslim men killed in the action had been linked with bombing in the capital. “It is no wonder that the minority community feels victimized,” says Joshi. “Even within the police, there is a divide which shows up in their dealing of communal problems. Numerous inquiry commissions have noted that prejudice exists among the police.”

More worrying are increasing allegations of encounters being staged. In February 2007, two senior officials of Jammu and Kashmir police were stripped of their rank and arrested on charges of running a rogue operation in which fake encounters were staged in the central Kashmir district of Ganderbal in December 2006. The officers remain in custody facing charges of killing at least five innocent people, and planting evidence to imply that the victims had been insurgents.

In April 2007, a top cop in Gujarat, D.G. Vanzara, was arrested along with nearly a dozen other officers, in connection with the killing of a petty criminal, Sohrabuddin Sheikh, and his wife Kausarbi, in November 2005. Vanzara was convicted of planting false evidence at the scene of the shooting to create the impression that the pair had been involved with a Lashkar-e-Toiba terrorist plot against Chief Minister Nahendra Modi. The state of Maharashtra has a list of nearly half a dozen disgraced “encounter specialists” — earlier hailed as heroes, they now face charges ranging from staging encounters to amassing wealth through corrupt means. “This trend has criminalized the entire police force,” says Joshi, “It has serious implications for our democracy, for our social fabric, for our criminal justice system. It is undermining the very foundations of democratic policing.”

Adds Grover, each time Indian security forces are shown to have cried wolf about Pakistan-based terror plots, they undermine India’s credibility in the face of genuine foreign-sponsored terrorism.

Share